Hello again!
Do you remember a post I made a while back, in which I recreated a day's worth of Victorian meals? Well, I decided to roll up my sleeves and do it again! This time however I was recreating meals from the 1920s, 1921 to be specific, almost exactly 100 years ago.
After the problems I had with timing last time, I chose slightly simpler recipes this time round, and had LOTS of help from my delightful kitchen elves, (also known as my mom and brother.). I maintained the same rules from last time.
- As much as possible, keep to tools that were already around, IE I needed to use my stove and oven, but the rubber scraper? (as I’m not sure when that was originally invented) Not really a need no (Although I COULD use the mixer now!).
- Use authentic recipes as much as possible. Being one of two vegetarians, with two people with gluten sensitivities as well as living in a house FULL of lactose intolerances, some things did need to be tweaked slightly.
Also just like last time to keep as much authenticity as possible all the recipes were taken from the Atlanta Woman’s Club Cook Book, copyright 1921. Got it? Ready, set, go!
For breakfast, we had scrambled eggs and egg bread. I meant to put carrot marmalade on top of the bread, but I put off starting the marmalade until this morning, and it cooked for about 45 minutes, (15 more than it was meant to) so it wasn't set, or cooled in time for breakfast, so I used butter instead, although strangely enough, it smells like ORANGE marmalade! The eggs were good, but nothing out of the norm, although I admit this may have been “user error” as it didn’t technically say to mix the eggs while they were cooking, but instead has you mix them BEFORE they hit the heat, and I just couldn’t leave them unattended. The bread was disappointing, “egg bread” was far less accurate than “baking soda bread” and other then that flavor it was quite forgettable.
For lunch, we had a very colorful meal composed of chicken salad, potato puffs, stuffed baked tomatoes, and “For a summer draught” (basically retro homemade lemon soda). The chicken salad was simple enough to make, but tasted absolutely amazing, although I did cut the mayo by a half a cup, for fear of drowning the poor vegan chicken which I used in favor of real chicken. As I looked through the cookbook, I noticed that it seems as though you could get away with labeling anything as “salad” so long as you served it on lettuce, in the 20’s odd right? The potato puffs were great, although we had a short moment of panic as breakfast was cooking; “Oh shoot, we’re going to need pre-mashed potatoes to make the puffs!’ after we had thought of that, the rest of the recipe was simple enough, and they tasted just as you would expect; like mashed potatoes with eggs. As you may remember, I did a stuffed tomato last time as well, although this one was SO different it felt like an entirely different dish! Rather than eggs, which could have refused to cook like last time, this recipe was cabbage based, leaving the end product oddly like coleslaw stuffed in a tomato. Although it was quite good! I should note that both I, and one of my marvelous kitchen elves did cheat slightly, using the blender which wasn't invented till 1922, but as it was a cheat of a single year, I have no guilt over this. As for the “Retro lemon soda” it was not only delicious it was also super fun to make! I thought you may enjoy this process almost as much as I did, so I have a video for you.
For dinner, we had Welsh rarebit, alligator pear (avocado) salad, sweet peach pickles, and fruit punch. The Welsh rarebit was a bit of its own adventure, as it had NO liquid in it at all! So after chasing a bit of half-melted cheese around the bottom of a hot pan for a minute or two, my mom walked over and said “shouldn’t there be some milk in there?” and although the recipe may have said no, we went with it anyways, as I had no idea what else we could do, this worked quite well I would like to note. It tasted quite good, although it was blander then I had expected, but I did replace the cayenne powder with chili powder since we don’t keep cayenne on hand, so that may be on me. The alligator pear salad was amazing, but being quite a simple recipe it tasted as you may expect, the dressing, however, was so good, we have already made plans to remake it later. The sweet peach pickle, although we assumed they would be amazing, due to the ingredients, and our love of pickles, were SO strong with spice and vinegar that they tasted medicinal, and made my mom’s tongue go numb. The fruit punch was unlike any punch I can remember having, as it had a tea as one of the main flavors, although it was too sweet, it was also amazing, and we are planning on making it again at a later date.
For dessert, we had Chocolate milk floats, and peppermint (candy cane) ice cream. The chocolate milk float was great, just as you would expect, I did use soy, vs dairy milk in the floats, but with real ice cream, I figured that would probably be for the best. The ice cream was another mini-adventure, I started it freezing about lunch-time (1:00) and by 10-11ish it STILL wasn't fully frozen, now I didn’t use any kind of ice cream churn, and the book was especially strange about this, as it did say in another section that you should have an “Ice-cream freezer”, in this recipe in particular however, it just said to “freeze” it, plus what is an ice cream freezer anyway? No, honestly I can’t find this online! So I winged it, and just chucked it in the freezer, as we don’t keep an ice cream churn, let alone a vintage style one! Flavor-wise however, it was great, being flavored with candy canes it is just as good as you would think it should be.
So there you go, another experiment completed, this time with significantly fewer brain cells fried in the process. Although I am leaving this experiment very tired, physically and mentally, I can honestly say I enjoyed this one MUCH more than the last one, the food was better for the most part, and the workload much lighter. Not to mention much easier recipes, and how nice it was to be able to use the mixer! Much like last time, it was super informative and I am continuing to gain respect for the ladies who spent so much of their time in the kitchen, and still had time left for cleaning, and tending other tasks, not to mention maintaining their lives as well! I truly can not explain how much I feel for them while standing over a hot stove and turning small frazzled circles in the middle of the kitchen, it is almost like stepping into such a tiny part of the lives people used to live, it is absolutely surreal and really neat.
Thanks for the read!